what weed is it? putting names to pesky plants
I KNOW A LOT OF PLANTS BY THEIR PROPER NAMES, but when it comes to “weeds,” as we term unwanted garden visitors that seem to just come with the territory, my knowledge really paled until recent years. Lately, on days not conducive to outdoor work, I’ve been studying up from some great weed-identification websites, so that I can finally address Alliaria petiolata (garlic mustard, above) with the proper (dis)respect.
I didn’t even remember the botanical Latin name for the ubiquitous dandelion, Taraxacum officinale, below, until I became a regular on the Rutgers New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station “weed gallery” recently. The Rutgers weed tool is generally appropriate for my region, and I can browse by common names or by thumbnail photos (or by Latin names if I ever know one).
The University of Minnesota’s “Is This Plant a Weed?” tool is another place you’ll find me, narrowing the field of possibilities until I get an ID by clicking through a series of photo-based prompts (such as grass or broadleaf….upright or creeping…and so on). It almost makes weeds fun. (Note the almost.)
Steve Brill, the so-called “Wildman” forager who teaches in Central Park in New York City and elsewhere, has plant profiles of edible weeds on his website, if you’re hungry, with Brill’s advice you can serve up Japanese knotweed, dandelion greens and even plantain (though the latter’s not so tasty, below; Plantago major is better used on mosquito bites than on a dinner plate).
The University of California-Davis weed ID site is encyclopedic, and though I wish I could sort by images, once I get to them (on the plant profile pages) the information is some of the most detailed anywhere. They even show the weed in its seedling stage so you can eradicate it then without wondering if it’s your beloved self-sown something-or-other. See what I mean on a sample page (this one is bedstraw, Galium aparine, a common weed here as well).
With 172 species included, the University of Illinois has built an extensive weed database that’s browsable by common or Latin names, but with the added feature of filters (you can sort the list down to a certain flower color, for instance, or one of a series of very specific taxonomic keys, like leaf size, width, or the arrangement of the leaves. This one will get you sharpening your powers of observation.
The Virginia Tech and Virginia Cooperative Extension’s weed identification tool helps you narrow your choices, too, by similar methods. And Clemson University had a weed-identification search tool, too.
Likewise, the Integrated Pest Management website of the University of California has a great weed reference database.
I own a number of weed guides, some more booklet-sized than book, and was happy to find a full-color one posted free online. “Weeds of the North Central States” is available as a sample PDF to “page” through, should you happen to live in them there states, and you can buy the whole thing for $5 here.
Want to know which ones are so bad they have made their names on the state-by-state “noxious weeds” lists? The real Bad Boys of Weed-dom.
As many weeds as there are, there are apparently as many sources to learn about then, and if it’s old-school you want–with a full-fledged field guide at your side–I use this one (above), or most often of all the best one for my region, “Weeds of the Northeast” (affiliate link) co-authored by Richard Uva (below). I could go on, but then you’d think I’d grown a bit obsessed with weeds at the moment, wouldn’t you?
some of my first-name-basis weeds, and control ideas
- Clearweed, or Pilea pumila
- A weed I accidentally planted, Houttuynia or chameleon plant
- Mugwort and Prunella
- Why I leave jewelweed in some areas
- Clearweed (Pilea pumila)
- Commelina and Galinsoga
- Hedge bindweed and spotted spurge
- Horticultural vinegar herbicide, pros and cons (and safety!)
- Do home remedies work for weeds?
- Solarization and tarping, a 101
- Smothering weeds with cardboard and newspaper
- Piling on the mulch for weed suppression and control
- An all-season approach to weed control
- What about poison ivy?
Garlic mustard, I have a lot of it growing this year, never had it last year. I have browsed the weed sites and I love the thumbnails. Make for easy identification.
So that’s what it is. Now how the heck do I get rid of it? I’ve been pulling it up for 3 years. The roots seem to run clear to Shanghai!
You might also enjoy “Weeds of the Northeast” by Richard Uva and others. Nerd that I am, it’s a good read.
(Is garlic mustard edible?? I could set up a stand at a farmers market.)
Thanks Margaret – the Rutgers site (especially thumbnails) is great. You really provide a great service on your blog. They didn’t have such a thing when I lived in NJ but it’s useful now in southern Maine.
THANK you, Margaret,
For all those wonderful reference links! Doubt I’ll get to them any time soon – too busy trying to get rid of the weeds I already know before they can set seed (grrrr) – but it’s terrific to have so much research help gathered on a single page. I’m sure this post is going to be a hardy perennial and one of your Greatest Hits.
Thanks for the pointer to the Rutgers weed tool! I’ve wondered many a time what weeds were jostling my other plants around. It looks like it will be very helpful, especially since it is regional (we’re in Poughkeepsie NY).
Welcome, Emily, and I was glad to find it myself — and happy to share. Really makes a difference to have these visually driven ID guides, right? I feel smarter already. :) See you soon again, I hope.
@Garlic mustard. Should’ve said ( since I’m sure it’ll come up :-) ) that garlic mustard is indeed edible. Eat-your-weeds enthusiasts recommend it all the time. But for most people it’s a pretty powerful purgative when eaten as a spinach substitute like pigweed or lambs quarters. We sometimes put a few leaves in salads or make it into early-season pesto but that’s about the right dosage level unless you’re looking for a spring tonic.
Thank you for doing all the footwork and gathering so much helpful information for us and putting it all together in one place. Greatly appreciated.
Thanks Margaret! I was relying on my old weed id notebook from my Cornell weeds class and it was very skewed towards troublesome weeds in production agriculture. I bookmarked every site!
Thanks for this great resource. I’m finding this a huge challenge now because I can’t tell a weed sprout from a lettuce sprout. It’s so hard when they’re tiny – you almost have to wait until the mature some! I’ll be bookmarking this page.
Thank you for the reference materials. I love the Rutgers weed tool!
However,, as a native plant fan, I have to say that not all of these plants are invasive, nor should we seek to obliterate them. One of the prettiest “gardens” near me is an unplanted cornfield–now a meadow full of grasses and flowering plants that most would consider “weeds.” Remember the adage, “One man’s weed is another man’s wildflower.” Words to live by.
We have a terrible choke weed that I really believe came in with sleet last winter. It’s everywhere with runners!
Welcome, Catherine. Ack! Sounds like you have much fun ahead. All my “favorite” weeds are awakening fast, and I am not sure where to turn first. See you soon again, I hope.
Thank you! What great resources.
I’ve been yanking out great fistfuls of garlic mustard, but not knowing what it was. Have you noticed the smell when you rip it out? I kept thinking there was something burning, it has a strange singed smell. Ground ivy, on the other hand, smells really nice when I destroy it.
Margaret,
Thank you!! Your timing is just perfect.
Do you have any tips for what to do when the mulch/compost you receive is filled with weeds – they are all over the place!
I am ordering from your source this year, so will hopefully have better luck than last year – still weeding…..
Thanks for the links! Years ago I worked at a weed science laboratory. (Yes, there is such a thing.) While I was there I got a copy of a Weed Identification Guide produced by the Southern Weed Science Society. I’m sure it’s been updated many times since I worked there but I refer to it often. Each weed has pictures of seeds, seedlings, and mature plants with a few characteristics and distribution. It’s not complete though, so these sites will come in handy.
If anyone knows a way to get rid of the accursed purple bellflower wandering through my entire yard, I beg of you to let me know. Otherwise thanks for the weed-ID lessons!
Thanks for the weed sites! I’ve got some popping up in my garden, and I’ve been wondering if it was something I planted or something I should pull. Hopefully, one of the sites you listed can help!
Welcome, Dawn. I know exactly the situation you are describing; here, too. Just started at a clump of seedlings in one bed scratching my head as to whether they are friend or foe. :) See you soon again, I hope.
Have to tell you a funny story. We use to have a weather man on our local TV station that was a jokester. Anyway…he brought in a BIG weed plant one day (roots & all), and said the rain had been so good for the “weeds” lately. Well the other anchor man spoke up and said “what did you call that again”? So the weather man said the name again. The other anchor man laughed and said I know it by another name. My father always called it “THAT DARN WEED” ! As in “go pull up that darn weed” ! LOL. So that is what we call them here. THAT DARN WEED !
I think I have them all, and last year was so bad. I will probably spend all summer just combating the weeds that went to seed-ugh!
Margaret, I am planning on coming to your talk tomorrow night at the Chappaqua Library-I can’t wait.
I’m busy putting out fires in every bed. What the voles haven’t eaten or damaged, the weeds are quickly covering. Thank you for the great weed sites.
When I moved to the NW Corner of CT almost 11 years ago, I quickly identified garlic mustard as the noxious stalker of my gardens and woods. Research told me it was also known as “poor man’s salad’ to early settlers, and that its garlic-flavored leaves gave its common name. I had so blinkin’ much of it I did make a salad, which tasted along the lines of dandelions and other strong wild edibles, and it was tolerably palatable with a nice balsamic vinaigrette and feta. Unfortunately, I couldn’t win over my husband, so I set about obliterating it. Techniques I’ve developed: First, trace the often horizontal stem to where it enters the earth. When the ground is wet [after a soaking rain is ideal], small ones “wiggle” pull fairly easily; larger ones benefit from a deep, narrow weeding tool loosening the ground first, then wiggling them out. Pulling hard and straight breaks their root stalk and they’re back with vigor. [It it does break, excavate the root’s top, and pull it out.] A variation is to grasp it at the ground, and while using your hand as a wedge/lever against the soil, pull steadily, slowly “rolling” your hand away from the anchor point of its entry. Don’t yank, ease it out. For the mats of tiny seedlings in the leaves, etc., I scuffle my foot amongst them and break their grip on the ground. If I can’t get to the grownups in earnest, I’ll lop off their flower heads as a stop-gap to keep them from going to seed until I can come back at them. I keep policing through the summer and attack them again in the fall when they seem to get a 2nd wind. It’s taken me a decade, and this year is the first I’m not overrun with an advancing army of them. I do sneer at the roadside platoons of them as i drive by; unfortunately, they don’t wither from my hurled epithets.
Garlic mustard was the very plant I wanted to identify. Thanks for all your real help, as always.
Welcome, Mary Lou. I think I have the world’s leading collection of the stuff…yikes. What a nuisance. Don’t let it flower, is my motto. Dig, pull, dig, pull…and early. Have upended bushels already here. See you soon!
Thanks–I was confused between 2 different garlic mustard-looking things I saw today out on our dog walk, and wanting to look that up. It was also impossible to miss the copious wild parsnip, one of the bad boys, sprouting everywhere. When it’s high I won’t take the dog through the fields where it is–too scared of those photos of burned skin. It’s really taken over roadsides and some hay fields out here.
Saw a very interesting talk at the Arnold Arboretum in Boston the other night by a guy who has written a guide to what he calls “spontaneous urban vegetation.” Turns out some of these weeds are actually helping matters.
here’s how the event was described:
Our cities and towns may seem harsh and unwelcoming to vegetation, but in the new field guide, Wild Urban Plants of the Northeast by Harvard botanist Peter Del Tredici, details the spectacular array of plants that grow spontaneously in sidewalk cracks, flourish along chain-link fences, and line the banks of streams and rivers. Del Tredici will discuss the valuable ecological roles these plants play, from carbon storage and erosion control to providing food for wildlife.
Welcome, Fran. Peter Del Tredici is quite a respected member of botanical circles, and it sounds like it was a great talk. Thanks for the information. I found a PDF of an article by him on the topic that people can download by clicking the top link “Book Excerpt…” on this page from his site:
https://peterdeltredici.com/index.php?/research/peter-del-tredici-/
Hope to see you soon again.
Canada thistle is the bane of my gardening existence. If I only had a goat!